Wednesday, March 01, 2006

Lingering Questions

I've been reading Philemon a lot lately. I know it's a short book, but I've been reading it over and over and over, and thinking a lot about how we read scripture.

I'm developing my thinking, my understanding on how it is we are to read the New Testament - individually and in a community of faith - but still struggling to understand exactly how to do this.

Not that there's necessarily just one way, but I'm sure there are some ways that are better than others...

When the Apostle Paul was writing, he treated each situation as unique and important. His letters do not so much forge religious dogma as convey his understanding of how Christianity (read: the Gospel) might be structured in concrete situations.

While the letters function today in the canon of scripture as the “Word of God,” we must consider what this means. If Paul was knowingly writing different letters with different styles, based on different contexts, might we not also consider the necessity of contextualizing the gospel to our own cultural, social, and economic situation? 

Is it not, then, dangerous to absolutise these scriptural passages and superimpose solutions addressing issues of the first century church upon our own world without contextual nuance?

How then are we to read Paul's letters today?

Technorati Tags: , , , ,

3 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hm...but we aren't Paul. If we believe that the scriptures are divinely inspired and not merely authored by man, then it should seem dangerous for us to take license from the MAN who physically wrote the scriptures and apply them to our everyday, rather than looking to the God who authored them for the universality of those scriptures..no? Hm...I might have totally caught the wrong sense of what you were questioning, but you've got an interesting thought.

2:22 p.m.  
Blogger andrew said...

i suppose the next question to ask is, where exactly does revelation take place? is it in Christ? in other historical events? in Paul's hearing of these events? in the development of his understanding as a part of a community of faith? in his authoring of the letters?

does revelation occur in the text as cannon? in the teaching office of the church? in our personal interaction with the scripture?

my suspicion is that it doesn't take place just at one of these points. tho neither would i submit that it necessarily has to take place at all points along that line.

these are the questions i'm asking right now.

i completely agree that we have to look at the scriptures as being divinely inspired, written by a man. but can we say that revelation only occurred in God's work through Paul?

if God is still active in the world today, if he has revealed himself in many ways (even as a son), then he must have something to say to us now, through the scriptures and through other methods of revelation.

i'm not advocating the relativisation of scripture, but i am asking the question of how we should read, say, philemon, today.

how would / how do you go about it?

2:41 p.m.  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Revelation...my Catholic school days answer always had to be 1-Scripture 2-Tradition
3-Magisterium. All including and encompassed of course by Christ Himself. Hm...I'm going to have to do some lectio divina with Philemon, but as a whole, public revelation stopped with the apostles. Private revelation still continues...apparitions, etc..but do not add to the doctrine of the faith and do not damage your faith if you do not believe in them.

Now a simple part in the introduction to Philemon in my Bible says this "Paul, by presenting Onesimus as 'brother beloved...to me but even more so to you' voiced and idea revolutionary in that day and destined to break down worldly barriers of division 'in the Lord.'"

How would I read Philemon? I would say within the framework of my faith, with humility, seeing that (as you said) God's word is not relative, and Searching for an echo of Christ's teachings in early Christian tradition.

Mmm..I don't think I'm actually being any help, so maybe I'll just stop here and pray for you to get more educated guidance on this topic....(Long Day.) :) Might I suggest looking for a Dominican nearby?

4:46 a.m.  

Post a Comment

<< Home